Most of the difference comes from three things: the size of the system, what happens to the ductwork, and what is included in the price. A quote that does not mention the permit, HERS test or removal of the old equipment is not cheaper. It is incomplete.
Use the checklist below, then let ChatGPT read each quote for you.
What Should You Ask Any HVAC Contractor?
Ask the same questions of every company you are comparing. Any licensed HVAC contractor should be able to show these five things in writing. Put a check next to each one the quote covers. A verbal promise does not count.
| Every quote should show in writing | Quote 1 | Quote 2 | Quote 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| How the home was measured, room by roomRoom sizes, windows and ceiling heights, not only the total square footage | |||
| Manual J load calculation for each roomThe size of the system should come from this number | |||
| Manual D duct designHow each duct is sized for the air each room needs | |||
| Permit, city inspection and HERS test in the priceNamed in the scope, not “if required” | |||
| Who prepares the rebate applicationAnd which documents you will get for it |
- How did you measure the house, and can I see the room-by-room Manual J?
- Are you keeping my ducts, and did you check their size and condition?
- Are the permit, city inspection and HERS test in this price or extra?
- What are the exact model numbers and the AHRI number?
- Did you check my ducts for leaks before sizing the system?
- We scan the home in 3D and measure every room
- We size the system with a room-by-room Manual J
- We design the ducts with Manual D
- We handle the permit, city inspection and HERS test and show them in the written scope
- We prepare the rebate paperwork for you
- Exact model numbers in writing before any work begins
What Does Each Line of the Checklist Mean?

- MeasurementsSomeone walked the house and measured it, or scanned it in 3D. Room sizes, windows, ceiling height and insulation all change the load.
- Manual JThe ACCA standard for residential load calculation. Done room by room, it shows how much heating and cooling each room needs, not just the house as a whole.
- Manual DThe ACCA standard for duct design. It sizes each run so the air from the new system reaches every room.
- Permit, inspection and HERSIn California, replacing a central system needs a permit. Title 24 also calls for a HERS test on most replacements. Both should be named in the scope.
What a room-by-room Manual J looks like


Three rooms from the floor plan above:
| Room on the plan | Area, sq ft | Airflow it needs, CFM |
|---|---|---|
| Living room | 333 | 315 |
| Bedroom | 205 | 247 |
| Sun room | 68 | 308 |
The sun room is a fifth the size of the living room and needs almost the same air. A quote sized from square footage alone would never show that. This is the page to ask for: if a contractor can’t show you numbers by room, the ducts weren’t designed by room either.
What Does a Quote Check Look Like?
Here is a typical exchange. A homeowner has a quote for a 5-ton system for a 1,400 sq ft house.
For comparison, a real calculation: the 1,788 sq ft Altadena home above came out to 42,430 BTU per hour of cooling, about 3.5 tons, and 72,282 BTU per hour of heating. Another house of the same size can land somewhere else, because windows, walls and ducts decide, not the floor area.
How Can ChatGPT Help You Check an HVAC Quote?
An AI assistant is good at reading a long estimate, explaining each line in plain English and noticing what is missing. Copy a prompt, fill in the brackets, and attach your estimate as a PDF or a photo. Use the same prompts on every quote, so the answers are comparable.
Is the size right?
A contractor recommends a [tons]-ton [heat pump / AC and furnace] for my [square feet] sq ft, [year built] home in [city], California. What should a proper ACCA Manual J load calculation include, and what should I ask to confirm this size is right?What’s missing from the estimate?
Here is my HVAC estimate: [attach]. Explain each line in plain English and list anything usually part of a full replacement in California that is missing or vague: permit, HERS test, ductwork, return air, thermostat, removal of old equipment, warranty.What about my ducts?
My contractor plans to [keep / replace] my ducts. [Describe rooms that are too hot or cold.] What is Manual D duct design, when do old ducts need replacing, and what should I ask before deciding?Which rebates could apply?
My utility is [GWP / LADWP / BWP / PWP / SCE / SoCalGas] and I'm considering a [heat pump / AC / furnace]. What rebates might apply, what equipment do they require, and which official pages should I check?Compare my quotes
I have [number] HVAC quotes: [attach]. Compare them on equipment and capacity, how the size was calculated, ductwork, permits and testing, warranty and price. What does each one leave out, and what should I ask each contractor?

What Are the Red Flags in an HVAC Quote?
These are the gaps we see most often when homeowners show us other bids. Any one of them is a reason to ask a question before you sign.
- No permit and no HERS test in the scope
- No flushing of the old refrigerant lines
- No refrigerant recovery
- No FIKR32 leak detection kit for an R-32 AC on an existing gas furnace
- No secondary drain pan with a float switch
- No load calculation
- No exact model numbers and no AHRI reference number, the certificate that confirms the outdoor and indoor units are rated to work together
Check Any HVAC Quote With ChatGPT
“Choose the contractor, not the equipment. There is no limit to the corners someone can cut: brazing without nitrogen, kinked lines, a sloppy condensate drain, a unit that is not level, no calibration, the wrong refrigerant charge. You will not see any of it on installation day. You will see it later, when water drips from the attic or the system fails in five years because of mistakes nobody could see.”Alex Butakov, co-founder, Cold Cloud Mechanical
FAQ
How many HVAC quotes should I get?
Three is usually enough to see where the sizes and scopes differ. More quotes help only if each one is checked against the same list.
Is the cheapest HVAC quote a bad sign?
Not by itself. Check what it leaves out first. A low price with no permit, no HERS test and no load calculation is a different job from a higher price that includes them.
Can I ask a contractor for the Manual J calculation?
Yes. If the system was sized with Manual J, the contractor has the report and can show it to you. If there is no report, ask how the size was chosen.
Does a new HVAC system need a permit in California?
Replacing a central heating or cooling system needs a permit from your city or county, and Title 24 calls for a HERS test on most replacements. Your contractor pulls the permit. Make sure it is named in the quote.
- ACCA Manual J, residential load calculation: acca.org
- ACCA Manual D, residential duct design: acca.org
- California Energy Commission, Title 24 Building Energy Efficiency Standards: energy.ca.gov
- AHRI Directory of Certified Product Performance: ahridirectory.org




